« Blog Home
1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars
Loading ... Loading ...

Wian du Preez 7 — Good, solid if unspectacular debut. Welcome onboard son. Good to have a sound alternative to Beast.

Adriaan Strauss 7 — Again. Solid, no fireworks, but not much wrong either. Also handy to have when Bismarck needs a rest. They are doing some seriously good work in the Free State with their front-rowers.

John Smit 7 — One of his best showings this year in my view. Even better when moved to hooker. Nice little selection/positional poser for the coaching staff there.

Bakkies 7 — Far, far better performance than against France. Still not his best though.

Andries Bekker 7 — Solid at lineouts if not quite dominant. A highlight on this tour has been his improvement in the loose.

Heinrich Brussow 8 — Brilliant again. SA’s find of the year? He brings a different and effective dimension to our loose forward play.

Danie Rossouw 6 — Mr Versatile didn’t have the most effective outing. Somewhat disappointing really. But oh that offload!

Ryan Kankowski 4 — Started off strongly. That run showed his class in open play. But as the match wore on he disappeared. He needs to work on his tight game next season.

Fourie du Preez 7 — Better showing. Solid and even, brilliant in flashes. Made those flashes count though.

Morne Steyn 5 — Seems to suffer when his kicking game is not on song as he doesn’t offer much more besides that. Was not as effective as he could have been.

Adi Jacobs 6 — Disappointing. Started off well but drifted in and out of the match as it progressed. He and Jaque Fourie do not seem to be gelling quickly enough.

Jaque Fourie 8 — Much better showing than in France. Great finishing for his try. His support of his inside centre needs to improve though. He could make many more line-breaks running off Adi’s shoulder.

Bryan Habana 7 — Busy and effective in equal measure. Point deducted for that ‘tache though. I’m all for following the leader, but let’s let PdV own the ‘tache area.

JP Pietersen 5 — Not much came his way really. Anonymous game.

Zane Kirchner 6 — Ordinary. Not bad, but not much good either. With Conrad Jantjes returning next year and Frans Steyn likely to return in time for the 2011 World Cup, he really needs to be making more of this extended run.

Subs

BJ Botha 7 — Made a difference when he came on. Welcome back, now please return to the Sharks so we can pick you more often.

Beast Mtawarira 7 — Played like the Beast we have come to know and love.

Victor Matfield — Good in the air. Okay in the loose. Needs a break. Which makes his Baabaas call-up perplexing.

Jean Deysel — Strong, dominant debut. The SA loose forward factory pops out another one.

Frans Hougaard — Not on the field long enough. Looked more confident than against Saracens though.

Ruan Pienaar — Less nervy performance, but not enough time to make a case.

Wynand Olivier — Finished his try well. Didn’t do much to advance his cause after the midweek disappointments.




Related Posts

10 Responses to “Bok ratings vs Italy”

Agreed.. Lets keep Smit as a starter hooker and take Bismark off the bench - Beast was a wonderful impact player and it reminded me of whn he was first starting out - he makes such an impact with fresh legs in the last twenty minutes, it might be worth using him in that role. Deysel to start over Kankowski and Tereblanche should be tried out at fullback next year, he may be older but hey hes in the form of his life. Need more depth at flyhalf than ruaan pienaar as well, he´s not cutting it - lets give that potgieter from Free State a chance. Not sure whats up with Heini Adams, he injured? Should definately be our number 2 number 9…

(Report abuse)

Steve on November 24th, 2009 at 2:22 pm

Hi Thankyou, I see you are having another crack at the rating system.
I read somewhere that players are not to keen on journos rating them out of ten, it has something to do with journos generally not knowing what they are talking about, yet still get to assess their performance by dishing out a number, apparently…oh well.
I did note your allegiance to Jacobs subsided somewhat, but then you did manage to somehow imply that his defensive misgivings are as much his partners fault…nice like what you did there.
Good luck next week with the ratings…it must be a difficult job being a players critic.

(Report abuse)

Banana on November 25th, 2009 at 12:33 pm

@ Banana - Isn´t that what sports about?

(Report abuse)

Steve on November 26th, 2009 at 9:15 am

I wouldn’t too if I was a player.

But I’m not, I’m a sports fan with an opinion. So I rate on.

Ps. Allegiance to Adi? Naah, I think you have the opposite though.

(Report abuse)

Bonga Ntshingila on November 26th, 2009 at 9:34 am

@ Steve- The JS situation is really quite a poser.

We scrum better with him at hooker, but Bismarck offers more around the park, which is where the Bokke have an edge over the opposition.

Also JS’s mobility (weight gain or not) was always going to suffer as time went on.

Nice headache to have still.

I still think our scrummie problems will be solved when Ricky drops 10kgs and gets his head right.

(Report abuse)

Bonga Ntshingila on November 26th, 2009 at 9:37 am

@Steve you mean the point of sports is to be rated out of ten? LOL maybe in gymnastics, but I doubt any sportman wakes up in the morning before a game asking themselves I wonder how I will perform today, hopefully a 7! I think you missed the point altogetehr about sports in that case, and thats a shame, there is a lot to be enjoyed.

@Bonga, I love Adi, as a Sharks supporter he has been great for us, but since his injury, he has struggled…mosatly on defense…you cannot blame Fourie for that no matter how hard you try.

Glad we cleared that up about you being only a fan, and not a player…your blogs will make more sense now.

(Report abuse)

Banana on November 26th, 2009 at 11:08 am

@banana nobody blamed Fourie for Adi’s perceived defensive struggles.

Fact is though Jacque’s supporting lines have not been great. Doesn’t make either of them a bad player. So don’t start a non-existent debate.

(Report abuse)

Bonga Ntshingila on November 26th, 2009 at 1:33 pm

@ Banana - The point of sports (especially rugby) is to be entertained… To discuss it with ur mates, on blogs etc… Who you think is better, who u think had a good game, who had a crap game - its what makes it fun… The idea is to have an opinion…

(Report abuse)

Steve on November 28th, 2009 at 12:20 am

and a rating out of 10 is one way of doing it - I really enjoy reading peoples opinions on each player like that… And if you are a proffesional rugby player you have to realize that being judged comes with the job…

(Report abuse)

Steve on November 28th, 2009 at 12:25 am

[…] the original post here: Sports Leader » Siyabonga Ntshingila » Bok ratings vs Italy Share and […]

(Report abuse)


Leave a Reply

All comments must be approved by our editors, click here to read the editorial guidelines for comments. Please allow some time for our editors to approve your comment after posting.

Send me the Thought Leader daily newsletter

profile
Bonga Ntshingila is a 25 year old avid sports fan,he had a promising youth sports career (as in coaches always promised he would play in the next match,and teammates always promised to moer him if he shanked yet another scoring opportunity).When he realised that maybe he wasn't going to be the next Andre Joubert thanks to a few shortcomings (hand-eye co-ordination,timing,pace (buffet lines excepted) he proceeded to satisfy his huge passion for sport from the stands and immerse himself in in-depth analysis of sport and atheletes.This may (not) have been made even more inviting by the prospect of imbibing a few refreshing beverages while casting a critical eye over the latest choke/cheat/fluke by (insert geographically correct team here) and telling all and sundry just how and why he and only he saw it coming.

Bonga indulges the following sporting passions:

1.Orlando Pirates (no I have never set any stadium on fire)
2. Rugby.anywhere and everywhere it is played on the planet
3. Curling

One of the above may be made up.
Technorati RSS
Siyabonga's links
The Richmark Sentinel
News, Views and all the information you need. All in one place and up to date.
more posts
So the nominations are in and the fierce lobbying, counter lobbying and electioneering starts. This elections, while not necessarily being the most cr...
Bulls Established Fourie du Preez. The IRB brainfart notwithstanding, he was indisputably head, shoulders and socks above every other player in ...
The Bulls: Take probably the best provincial/regional team ever assembled, lose probably the best winger of the last five years, add two returning her...
1. The Stormers will win the Super 14. That is the local pre-season tourney for the top 14 clubs in the Province/Boland area. 2. Rassie will dictat...
Team of the Year -- Close one between the *choke*Bulls*choke* and the Bokke here. I'll go for the Bokke purely on the fact that a Lions Series is a re...
latest activity
Blog Statistics
Total reads 18985
Total comments 329
Siyabonga's tags
advertisement
    Mail & Guardian Online Headlines
  • National
  • Business
  • Africa
  • World
  • Sport
All material copyright of the author, or the Mail & Guardian, unless otherwise specified
Author Login
Afrigator