« Blog Home
1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars
Loading ... Loading ...

The New Zealand Super 14 sides announced their squads in December. Yes, December. Meaning that two months before the start of the tournament the coaches had decided which thirty players they wanted to work with, and who needed to up their game some more.

Now what does a two-month head start mean? It means two months for players to work on their conditioning to get to the required levels; two months to learn the game plan; two months to get to gel as a unit; and two months to set up and play friendlies so you can test your players under all the scenarios you want to. It also gives those who didn’t make the cut two months to jack up their act so by the time February comes they are well placed to take advantage of any injury/suspension/tactical opportunities that arise.

Now granted, it’s not as if our boys were lamming on the beach doing nothing all summer. There certainly was a lot of work being done, but under what conditions and with what end? A settled team environment means the team can start focusing on key objectives early and get their planning and approach to fixtures/tours etc in early. Also, by the time the tourney starts the levels of unity and understanding within the team should be at the kind of level our boys will only get once the tourney has already started.

Now we already have many factors working against our boys in Super Rugby. Travel schedules, referees, inconsistent and extreme weather and playing conditions and styles (one week in Perth and the next in Invercargill anyone?)always combine to give the Antipodeans a significant advantage each year. So why don’t we work on the one thing we can control, preparation, and give ourselves a better chance?

Before anyone starts with the predictable, I do not see what Makhenkesi Stofile and Bhutana Komphela have to do with when the Super 14 squads can be named. Other macro issues maybe. This though, is within the individual unions’ and coaches’ control. So why aren’t they doing their bit to help themselves?




Related Posts
  • None

5 Responses to “Super 14: Shooting ourselves in the foot?”

Look, those Antipodeans have a jolly hard time too. Their own back yards are clean and safe. They have the extra stress of coming to play in Africa for Pete’s sake! They run the risk of being bitten by a rabid poodle on their early-morning jog and then have to put up with Third World medical attention. The drinking water from their hotel taps might have those horrible rat-tailed maggots in it. And that’s not even near the potential horror of being chomped by a lion or stomped by a rhino. Or mugged by a tsotsi. Or run over by a minibus taxi driver steering his brakeless 20-passengered projectile with a vice-grip.

Perth and Invercargill are havens of calm order. You may be bored to death, but you won’t be gored to death.

(Report abuse)

Jon on February 7th, 2009 at 7:11 pm

Actually Mid November they already put out the 5 New Zealand Super 14 Squads.

Hopefully the SA results do not reflect the lateness of their squad release.

(Report abuse)

Tony McKeever on February 8th, 2009 at 8:33 pm

Our biggest problem as I see it is player
movement.The Free State Cheetahs are the hardest
and the Lions to a lesser extent.If half of the
Lions squad end up in Province there is not
much a coach can do but to start all over again.
It would be far better if S A Rugby contracted
the Super 14 players and did the player
distribution instead of the Provinces bidding
and offering players packages the smaller unions just cant compete with.This would prevent some
provinces ending up with an almost Springbok
squad and having players who would
have been first choices somewhere else,warming benches.
I used to watch almost every game but nowadays I choose my games carefully because with the constant player movement I find it difficult to see players who used to be my hero now play against my team,but perhaps I am just old fashioned and used to loyalty that does not exist anymore.

(Report abuse)

Cool Down on February 11th, 2009 at 9:59 pm

Captain O after having watched this weekends matches I now hope you have re-assessed your comments. The SA teams looked in better condition (generally) than their antipodean couzies. I would say that by delaying the announcement of the teams the players were not lured into the false sense of security of having a spot in the squad and kept up their intensity in the gym and on the practice fields.
After your woeful comments about Luke (I am your father) Watson - I am begining to doubt your skills as a commentator on Rugby Union. Should you like you can send your column to me for “editing” before posting at the supplied email address.

(Report abuse)

Craig Millar on February 16th, 2009 at 11:30 am

Hi Craig

Lets wait till at least 2 of our teams have been on tour to asses. So far only the Bulls have played Antipodean opposition, and given that the Reds without Chris Latham are a bit of a non-entity-its too early to tell.

(Report abuse)

Siyabonga Ntshingila on February 16th, 2009 at 12:10 pm

Leave a Reply

All comments must be approved by our editors, click here to read the editorial guidelines for comments. Please allow some time for our editors to approve your comment after posting.

Send me the Thought Leader daily newsletter

profile
Bonga Ntshingila is an avid sports fan,he had a promising youth sports career (as in coaches always promised he would play in the next match,and teammates always promised to moer him if he shanked yet another scoring opportunity).When he realised that maybe he wasn't going to be the next Andre Joubert thanks to a few shortcomings (hand-eye co-ordination,timing,pace (buffet lines excepted) he proceeded to satisfy his huge passion for sport from the stands and immerse himself in in-depth analysis of sport and atheletes.This may (not) have been made even more inviting by the prospect of imbibing a few refreshing beverages while casting a critical eye over the latest choke/cheat/fluke by (insert geographically correct team here) and telling all and sundry just how and why he and only he saw it coming.

Bonga indulges the following sporting passions:

1.Orlando Pirates (no I have never set any stadium on fire)
2. Rugby.anywhere and everywhere it is played on the planet
3. Curling

One of the above may be made up.
Technorati RSS
Siyabonga's links
Newstime
News, Views and incisive analysis. Newstime. All the time.
Newstime
News views and top notch analysis
more posts
Lonwabo Tsotsobe's devastating form against the Bangladeshis should, hopefully, have made the selectors sit up and take note. Having been consigned...
Arsenal have had a topsy-turvy time of it since their calamity against Birmingham in the Carling Cup final a fortnight ago. Victory against Leyton ...
Maybe Jermain Defoe has a future as a soothsayer. Just months after the often misfiring Tottenham Hotspur finisher was derided for saying Harry Re...
Firstly, before Arsenal throw their toys out the cot blaming ref Massimo Busacca, they must remember they had 90 minutes in which all they needed to d...
Only South Africans would, faced with the prospect of having two genuine world-class pivot prospects, seek to align among provincial lines and do thei...
latest activity
Blog Statistics
Total reads 27589
Total comments 357
Siyabonga's tags
advertisement
All material copyright of the author, or the Mail & Guardian, unless otherwise specified
Author Login
Afrigator