« Blog Home
1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars
Loading ... Loading ...

Watching the Springboks take on New Zealand this past weekend, I was struck by two rather profound thoughts. Firstly, that it still isn’t socially acceptable to drink hard liquor in the morning, judging by the disapproving looks I received from the other patrons at the coffee bar I was frequenting. Secondly — and most importantly — I was left convinced that the time has come for rugby to become a fully fledged summer sport.

It was telling that the professional wrestling manoeuvre Brad Thorn performed on John Smit proved to be the game’s most innovative passage of play. This was through no fault of the players, however, as the weather in Wellington was nothing short of atrocious. Pacific island villages have been evacuated for far less, and yet there we were, expecting a great game of rugby to be played. Watching the Springboks lose can be an unpleasant experience at the best of times; watching them lose in near-freezing conditions in the pouring rain is just pure masochism.

If one considers the Western Province versus Free State match later in the day, as well as the Italian mudbath from a few weeks back, it becomes fairly obvious that the game of rugby should be played in dry, humid conditions. Despite technological advances in the material used for making balls, as well as the emergence of those gloves that were so popular a few seasons back, rugby is and always will be a difficult game to play in the wet.

The average rugby fan has grown weary of the conservative tactics generally employed by teams in these conditions. If we really wanted to see aimless kicking from one side of the field to the next, we would go to a Bafana Bafana game. What we really want to see is entertaining rugby, consisting of intelligent running and slick handling, and the conditions need to be conducive for our teams to play in that manner,

Playing in the summer is not that radical or far-fetched an idea — the Super 14 usually starts around February anyway, and it’s no coincidence that it’s the most exciting rugby tournament in the world. All it really means, then, is pushing the season forward by another two months, which would actually help the players with their conditioning, as they would then be playing matches during the holiday period rather than filling up on Christmas pudding in their off-season. In terms of safety, professional rugby players tend to suffer from broken necks rather than heat exhaustion, so there is no medical bias against playing in sweltering humidity. Our local footballers have already made the seasonal transition fairly easily, and there is no reason why our rugby players cannot also make the change.

From a fan’s perspective, having the season in the warmer summer months would also lead to more braais, and wors and braaivleis have always played a vital part in the South African rugby supporter’s psyche. It’s a win-win situation any way you look at it. Sure, some traditionalists may baulk at the idea, preferring the forward-dominating scrap of a 9-3 score line on a muddy pitch in Newcastle rather than the high-octane 45-37 try-fest on a dry Highveld field. Let’s be realists here, though: in order for rugby to appeal as a truly global sport, it needs to up its entertainment levels — meaning more running, more tries and drier fields.

There is a reason why cricket isn’t played in winter. It’s time that rugby’s head honchos wised up and followed suit.




Related Posts

5 Responses to “Slippery when wet: Why rugby should be a summer sport”

I personally feel that the boys running around in wet jerseys & tighty whiteys is highly appreciative…

(Report abuse)

SheBee on July 8th, 2008 at 12:56 pm

The type of weather the all blacks are used to playing in,on home soil,could mean the next world cups,is almost guaranteed theirs.

I wonder if NZ has closed roof stadiums,otherwise the 2011 world cup,possibly played in miserable weather isnt going to be the best advert for the game, nor will the type of play; bad weather producing slowed down, kicking back and forth boring style rugby.Will be intersesting to see i suppose,which teams adapt to possible bad weather,or have their game completely sunk by it?

(Report abuse)

Mpho on July 8th, 2008 at 2:23 pm

@SheBee - Valid point, but some of us guys feel a little uncomfortable seing the likes of Victor Matfield running around in skimpy wet shorts.

@Mpho - I like your idea of playing in closed roof stadiums, in the long term I really see rugby going in that direction.

(Report abuse)

Shaun Oakes on July 10th, 2008 at 9:31 am

Call me traditionalist, old-fashioned, backwards even but I reckon I prefer playing/watching rugby in winter.

Yes, it can be boring but it’s up to the teams to bring the right strategy and tactics on the day.

You could argue that F1 would be better if it stuck to one location during the summer. That way we wouldn’t have to worry about ‘unrealistic’ results when half the field slips and slides their way out of the race, but it’s those very upsets in the sometimes monotonous races that make it interesting.

Apologies Mr Oakes, but we’re going to have to agree to disagree.

(Report abuse)

name.goes.here on July 10th, 2008 at 2:20 pm

@Name.Goes.Here - For rugby to rival the likes of football as a global game we need to sell it to the Americans. We will only be able to do that by upping the entertainment levels, which indirectly means doing away with wet weather conditions.

By the way, I’m not sure why you brought F1 into the equation - as everyone knows, this isn’really regarded as a sport. It’s more of a car procession?

(Report abuse)

Shaun Oakes on July 10th, 2008 at 4:36 pm

Leave a Reply

All comments must be approved by our editors, click here to read the editorial guidelines for comments. Please allow some time for our editors to approve your comment after posting.

Send me the Thought Leader daily newsletter

profile
A scholar and a gentleman, Shaun Oakes has many passions in life - including rugby, soccer and peeing in the shower.

Although mediocre at virtually every sport he has played, Oakes is nonetheless a passionate writer, and regularly shares his unique insight on various sporting codes.

When not getting harassed by Big Issue vendors or women with small feet, he also finds the time to run the surprisingly popular website www.shaunoakes.com.
Technorati RSS
more posts
Springbok rugby coach Peter De Villiers seems to be on a hiding to nothing. When his charges taste defeat – which has unfortunately happened rather ...
What a great time to be a Protea fan. No, I'm not referring to the flower, although I suppose this would also be a good time as spring is almost upon ...
Peter De Villiers has a diabolical taste in fashion, judging by his outlandish ties, garish shirts, and the cricket-styled pullovers he seems to be so...
The European football championships ended on Sunday in typically spectacular fashion, as the Spanish flummoxed and beguiled the workmanlike Germans to...
Watching the Springboks take on Italy this past weekend was about as enjoyable as having my car stolen, or breaking a leg. The atrocious weather c...
latest activity
Blog Statistics
Total reads 4788
Total comments 49
Shaun's tags
advertisement
All material copyright of the author, or the Mail & Guardian, unless otherwise specified
Author Login
Afrigator