« Blog Home
1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars
Loading ... Loading ...

So, word on the street is that the Europeans want the vuvuzelas to be banned from the Fifa Confederations Cup and 2010 World Cup. So what? Even the “Europeans” in Cape Province have previously alluded to the fear of black people blowing the horn in Greenpoint.

Ok. Maybe there is distortion abound. For the record, we do not blow the vuvuzela because we are Africans. We blow the vuvuzela because we get an adrenalin rush from the creative noise it makes. Also, we get an adrenalin rush because we are human. Not because we are Africans!

Now that we have moved away from the racial stereotype, it becomes easier to clear the noise. Subsequently, we could agree in unison that this is a matter of like, dislike and intolerance. Now, like and dislike is somewhat of an “acceptable” natural dichotomy. It is mainly the latter, which seems to dominate the vuvuzela uproar. And this intolerance has manifested itself in different angles over time.

Simply speaking, there was once intolerance about the possibility of an African country being afforded the opportunity to host the World Cup. And now there is intolerance about Africans enjoying the vuvuzela sound.

Did I mention that this is a general manifestation of intolerance? No. I’m not just generalising!

Over the past two weeks of the Fifa Confederations Cup I’ve overheard two white brothers being told to “take a chill pill”. And that is putting it nicely. The alternative would be that I overheard two black guys remind two white guys that the apartheid-cum-colonial honeymoon came to an end (15) years ago. And these were two separate incidents.

Just so we clear the confusion, I’m still not talking about racial/cultural stereotypes. I’m talking about the problem with intolerance. Reality on the ground suggests that the natives have gone restless and are angry. And they are blowing vuvuzelas!

As the hosts for the two big Fifa events, I do not think South Africans can afford to be rude and arrogant, but our guests must still observe a code of conduct. And the core principle is tolerance!




Related Posts

20 Responses to “On the vuvuzela and tolerance”

“We blow the vuvuzela because we get an adrenalin rush from the creative noise it makes” —- ikona boetie—- your creative noise are the same sounds coming from a swarm of bees! Now here is an idea —- why not sell a mp3 version of your creative noise as a ringtone!

(Report abuse)

Ray Mc Oily on June 23rd, 2009 at 3:53 pm

MAY THE SOUND OF THOUSAND VUVUZELA’S FOLLOW YOU DOR THE REST OF YOUR DAYS…. AND MAY THE CREATIVES SOUNDS OF A MILLION VUVUZELA’S BE YOUR CHURCH’S VERSION OF MOZARTZ’S DEATH MARCH AT YOUR FUNERAL! VIVA’S AND GLORY

(Report abuse)

Pastor Ray Mc Oily on June 23rd, 2009 at 4:00 pm

Allow me to make some racial generalisations, if I may. Southern African Blacks are among the most harmonious singers in the world, or at least among the most harmonious I have heard. I apologise for generalising. From young, creative harmonising and creative singing in unison seems to be inculcated by Southern African Blacks.

Good grief, surely sixty thousand people singing creative harmonies in unison would be sooooo much better than sixty thousand disharmonious off key vuvizelas?

Just a thought, a generalised one I know, but a thought nevertheless.

(Report abuse)

D Froneman on June 23rd, 2009 at 4:38 pm

hhhmmm racial intolerance ? think you have dived into the deep end here. is it not just a case of whinging europeans not liking the noise and therefore moaning to FIFA ?

i don’t think there is anything racial about it .. if there was they would presumably be fine if white fans were blowing on them ?

maybe its you who needs to take a chill pill ;-)

(Report abuse)

beegee on June 23rd, 2009 at 4:57 pm

In Germany 2006, it was forbidden to sell German beer in the stadium, because Budweiser was the official sponsor. FIFA was criticized and they came back saying that the World Cup didn’t belong to Germany, but to FIFA, and that they have control on what goes inside and out of the stadium. Therefore, it’s up to FIFA, not to South Africans, not to the rest of the world, to establish what’s allowed in the stadiums. I have only heard complaints about this annoying (for lack of better term) noise. Myself, in particular, I found it quite irritant. I am also surprise about racism talks in this article. I’ve visited quite a few websites around the world and I am yet to see someone who mentioned that. This article is the first one which brought that up.

(Report abuse)

Caca on June 23rd, 2009 at 7:04 pm

Setumo playing the race card ….

So the Vuvu is an African thing?? The FIFA 2010 fiasco is not an “African” thing .. it is an international thing. The fact is that SA is only hosting the tourno, and trying hard to get as many international visitors to SA next year. So, have a bit of understanding that most non-Africans find the V-noise irritating in the extreme. I doubt that many non-African countries aspire to be anything like “African”, given the general mayhem, murder, & mis-Government that exists in this sick Continent.

Go blow your horn somewhere else Setumo!

(Report abuse)

atom on June 24th, 2009 at 8:54 am

I can tolerate the foreigners’ complaints about the Vuvuzela… It IS an ‘acquired sound’… What annoys me more than the monotonous ’singing’ by European fans though, is Locals who, after more than a decade of the Vuvuzela being an integral part of Football culture here, are only complaining now. Clearly these are not true African football fans and should be the least of our concerns. As for the foreigners… Relax, like the Dutch coach said… You do get used to it after a while. Oh and learn to blow…

(Report abuse)

Kiki on June 25th, 2009 at 12:11 am

I can tolerate the foreigners’ complaints about the Vuvuzela… It IS an ‘acquired sound’… What annoys me more than the monotonous ’singing’ by European fans though, is Locals who, after more than a decade of the Vuvuzela being an integral part of Football culture here, are only complaining now. Clearly these are not true African football fans and should be the least of our concerns. As for the foreigners… Relax… Like the Dutch coach said, you do get used to it after a while. Oh and learn to blow…

(Report abuse)

Kiki on June 25th, 2009 at 12:14 am

the vuvuzela sucks. it is painful and annoying. it isnt even traditional. i dont remember vuvuzelas at the africa cup of nations final in the mid nineties. i was there and i found it excellent. and f you for playing the race card. blow it up your bum.

(Report abuse)

Drunkmonk on June 25th, 2009 at 10:30 am

Blow the virtual vuvuzela at http://blowme.co.za and keep it at the game

(Report abuse)

Jan Laubscher on June 26th, 2009 at 11:26 am

@mcOlly - As a Texan, I would totally buy that ringtone.

All this uproar over the vuvuzela is silly. If it doesn’t sound nice on TV, then the broadcasters should turn the stadium mics down. I just learned of the vuvuzela by watching the Confederations Cup, and it makes me want to go to the WC even more. Drinking some beers and making a glorious racket while watching top-notch international football sounds wonderful, and maybe I can get a bunch of mzansi and kwaito records while I’m down there, since they’re in very short supply in my part of the world. Based on what I’ve seen of the Confederations cup, it seems like WC2010 is going to be a wonderful event for South Africa and the world.

(Report abuse)

wtfbbq on June 27th, 2009 at 12:42 am

that’s funny, i just blogged today about the whole vuvuzela thing.

ugh. i would have been homicidal if people played vuvuzelas in the senegalese national stadium in dakar, seeing that the stadium was oh, about 700 meters from my house. [if you know dakar, that’s p.a. unité 26.]

my gripe, which i’ve outlined in my blog just before reading it on here, is that they are being presented as “african” and not “mzansi”. um, no.

personally, i don’t like the sound. [and for the record, i’m not a big fan of the drunken boors in europe either.] that said, i’m a bit upset of it being presented as something that’s “authenic african” whatever that is supposed to mean.

i’m seriously tempted to rent my house out and sit out this world up in brazil. i need the us$ to strengthen a bit so i can make that happen, though.

(Report abuse)

mundundu on June 28th, 2009 at 11:58 am

Look, is plain and simple and it has nothing to do with racial/cultural stereotypes nor intolerance nor tolerance. The vuvuzela is plain and simpley irritating. I was at the Italy / Brazil match and had two WHITE gentleman behind me blowing the vuvuzela. In short, I did not enjoy the match at all!!!

(Report abuse)

Marco on June 29th, 2009 at 9:50 pm

[…] writes about the vuvuzela and intolerance: For the record, we do not blow the vuvuzela because we are Africans. We blow the vuvuzela because […]

(Report abuse)


The thing is South Africa actually has great football songs and does not need the plastic horn:

http://www.footballiscominghome.net/video/the-vuvuzela-conspiracy/

(Report abuse)

Fut on July 1st, 2009 at 4:51 am

Re: World Cup 2010

Here is a website allowing people to vote for or against this controversial “trumpet”

(Report abuse)

James on July 3rd, 2009 at 3:22 pm

Re: World Cup 2010

Here is a website allowing people to vote for or against this controversial “trumpet”

www.banvuvuzela.com

(Report abuse)

James on July 3rd, 2009 at 3:23 pm

grey on July 9th, 2009 at 1:31 pm

thankyou for playing the race card
i am from usa and not white so i think when i say its annoying it doesnt mean i being racist haha
its just annoying its like thousands of bees right next to your head
i would have come to SA for the world cup but now i rather stay home and maybe maybe watch the wc

(Report abuse)

dsg on August 8th, 2009 at 4:13 am

Football in South Africa is evolving, one day it will be as enoyable to watch live and on tv like rugby. Most people like hearing the referee’s comments, the players shouting, the crowd cheer or the crowd being dead quiet in a tense moment ust like our very popular rugby matches, the vuvuzela will be banned bu we must vote first, vote at http://www.banvuvuzela.com/

(Report abuse)

Chris on November 19th, 2009 at 7:58 pm

Leave a Reply

All comments must be approved by our editors, click here to read the editorial guidelines for comments. Please allow some time for our editors to approve your comment after posting.

Send me the Thought Leader daily newsletter

profile
“…one of (the) most prolific and controversial writers… his views have elicited scores of letters… strength in Setumo’s writing is that he is able to initiate new issues or cast a fresh light on existing ones.” – Peter Malherbe (Editor – Reporter.co.za)
Technorati RSS
Setumo's links
more posts
I note the extent to which the talks around ownership to the vuvuzela have since degraded to the shallow, and shudder with remorse as to how Africans ...
What's the first thing you think of when you have visitors coming to your house? Is it not entertainment? It should be. Well, that's if you do get vis...
Enough about the Confederations Cup now. Let's talk women. Seriously, I've heard a lot of "oooh, he is so cute" to last me until the 2010 World Cup. A...
A friend of mine won an autographed Bafana Bafana T-shirt. There were 20 glasses of different beers. Could he pick out Castle Lager? He did, and he wo...
Khaya Vhailafuri is a very skilled carpenter. He is also passionate about football. Unlike many a football analyst or commentator, I'm convinced that ...
latest activity
Blog Statistics
Total reads 9004
Total comments 84
Setumo's tags
advertisement
    Mail & Guardian Online Headlines
  • National
  • Business
  • Africa
  • World
  • Sport
All material copyright of the author, or the Mail & Guardian, unless otherwise specified
Author Login
Afrigator