« Blog Home
1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars
Loading ... Loading ...

“Scrum, scrum, scrum!” The immortal words whispered down from Springbok generation to generation. Someone must have forgotten to tell the vintage of 2009. The Springbok year-end tour is destined for the annals of disaster as the Springboks succumbed to their third tour defeat in a row against “SA - Racens” last night.

The English are a strange bunch. Fifty thousand people at Wembley to watch a motley bunch of legionnaires take on a beleaguered Springbok team! They must have smelt the blood, because it’s dripping scarlet from the South African 2009 tour effort.

I actually thought the team played quite well. Heini Adams battled gamely, Ruan Pienaar had a reasonable outing (if you ignore a crucial penalty and conversions missed and a drop kick out on the full), Andries Bekker was a tower of strength in the first half and the back three of Rose, Ndungane and Nokwe were full of running. With reference to my previous column I saw two players of genuine class: Alistair Hargreaves and Juan de Jongh.

The Springboks lost, quite simply, at scrum time. Both Saracens tries came after powerful scrums. The first try from a scrum on our ball with scrumhalf Francois Hougaard under pressure and his kick charged down. The following attacking scrum nearly led to a push over for Saracens and resulted in Barritt’s try. Add to that the number of short arm or full penalties conceded at the scrum time. When the Boks did get the ball out, they were going backwards at a rate.

The Boks are going to have to be twenty points better than their opposition if they’re going to win a match on tour with the way their scrum is being refereed. And there are only two left! I assume we’ll get past Italy. But Ireland?

What has happened to the Springbok scrum? No selection issues to blame it on this time — this was the power front row of CJ van der Linde, Adriaan Strauss and Wian du Preez. What happened to the days when Jake White used to say that the Maties III XV had better rankers than the Australian national team? The Springboks used to relish a chance to bump heads with their opposition. Last night they looked like nervous teenagers as they approached the first scrum. Clearly the refs have been watching our games and realised that our “Crouch, Touch, Engage” ensemble are deserving of a shrill blast on the whistle. I think our big boys in the front are too scared to push in case they get penalised for … pushing?

I won’t say too much about James Jones. Suffice to say that if Saracens hire him for all their home games, they’ll be hard to beat.

De Villiers has complained, he doesn’t understand why we are being penalised at scrum time. Me neither. But best he finds out fast. The scrum has eroded the Bok’s confidence and a loss to Ireland will make the Tri-Nations victory and the Lions series win seem like light years away.

Peter Church is the author of local thriller Dark Video, published in South Africa 2008 and Australia 2009.




Related Posts

6 Responses to “Scrumboks!”

[…] Sports Leader » Peter Church » Scrumboks! www.sportsleader.co.za/peterchurch/2009/11/18/scrumboks – view page – cached “Scrum, scrum, scrum!” The immortal words whispered down from Springbok generation to generation. Someone must have forgotten to tell the vintage of 2009. The Springbok year-end tour is destined… Read more“Scrum, scrum, scrum!” The immortal words whispered down from Springbok generation to generation. Someone must have forgotten to tell the vintage of 2009. The Springbok year-end tour is destined for the annals of disaster as the Springboks succumbed to their third tour defeat in a row against “SA - Racens” last night. Read less […]

(Report abuse)


These stats are not official but by reckoning the penalty count was 13 - 5 in Saracens favour (2nd half 8-1). The shortarms awarded were 2-0 to Saracens. I included in Saracens numbers the penalty awarded in front of the posts that Hougard converted as a drop goal. There were 21 scrums in total and the Springboks conceded 3 short arm penalties and 2 full penalties. Over and above the penalties, Saracens two tries came directly from scrum pressures.

(Report abuse)

Peter Church on November 19th, 2009 at 7:02 am

Yes Peter, the coach will need to get clarity on the interpretations of the laws as they are to be applied at scrum time. Also vital is to understand what will be applied by the next two referees at the tackle: sure, the tackler must be allowed to play the ball (from either side), but he has to be on his feet without his body weight supported in any other way. Surely also the tackled player has to be given a second (perhaps just a split second) to place the ball once tackled?

(Report abuse)

Paul Burton on November 19th, 2009 at 8:53 am

PDV seems to talking to a brick wall when trying to get answers from the IRB refs association…

(Report abuse)

Steve on November 19th, 2009 at 9:37 am

Our loose forwards should stick their heads in the scrum and start pushing. You can’t expect 5 to do the work of 8.

(Report abuse)

Marius de Kock on November 20th, 2009 at 9:41 am

Stephen Jones delivers a scathing (tongue in cheek?) putdown of South African scrummagers.
http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/sport/rugby_union/article6921703.ece

(Report abuse)

Peter Church on November 20th, 2009 at 10:42 am

Leave a Reply

All comments must be approved by our editors, click here to read the editorial guidelines for comments. Please allow some time for our editors to approve your comment after posting.

Send me the Thought Leader daily newsletter

profile
Peter Church is the author of the edgy thriller Dark Video, published by Struik in South Africa 2008 and New Holland in Australia 2009. He is a proud supporter of South African sport, especially the Proteas and Springboks. His earliest sporting memory is listening to the muddy 1970 Springbok-All Black second rugby Test on the radio in his Dad's car. He stills manages the odd cricket game for the renowned Ridge CC in Cape Town. He consults to the IT Industry and is currently working on a follow-up to Dark Video.
Technorati RSS
more posts
So the Springboks have an end of season Grand Slam tour scheduled. Very tempting to knock over Ireland, Wales, Scotland and England -- (throw in a gam...
Holed up at our beach cottage in the Eden district, I maintained an interest in the proceedings of the Third cricket Test between South Africa and Eng...
I had a feeling that the "Springboks" were going to lose to the Leicester Tigers on Friday night. The fixture reminded me of the torrid time the Irish...
By Peter Church In 1992, the Sydney rain came down on a gutsy SA cricket team's bid to win the prestigious Cricket World Cup. When Brian McMillan a...
latest activity
Blog Statistics
Total reads 1692
Total comments 34
Peter's tags
advertisement
    Mail & Guardian Online Headlines
  • National
  • Business
  • Africa
  • World
  • Sport
All material copyright of the author, or the Mail & Guardian, unless otherwise specified
Author Login
Afrigator