« Blog Home
1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars
Loading ... Loading ...

THE love-hate relationship between perennial country snob Benni McCarthy and Bafana Bafana continued unabated at Nasrec this week.

Benni, the lad many folks would love to loathe, is back in the Bafana Bafana squad.

And already the bets are going around on whether or not the ‘Prodigal One’ will check-in at the London hotel on Sunday at Bafana camp.

If he doesn’t, it won’t be the first time and, trust me, not the last time that this prima donna has turned his back on the country of his birth at a moment when he is most needed.

To borrow from his words of wisdom, Benni once exclaimed that “I don’t need Bafana, they need me,” and as much as I hate to agree with him, he is right.

After all, he is Benni McCarthy and, in his words “the most successful player to come out of this country”. He is the ‘Special One’ and deserves special treatment. It is for these reasons that, in my years as a sport writer, I have had to write more stories about this fellow from the Cape Flats absconding from camp than his glorious moments.

Why should I then bother about Benni?

Don’t get me wrong, he has been one of the leading figures at Bafana Bafana. He has been the star; the boy who has always played with our emotions; the lad who got fame out of representing his country (Malaysia 1997) and then betrayed the same people who had cheered him to stardom.

His call-up for the Australia game comes on the heels of his recent snub when he bailed out of Bafana Bafana’s crucial Africa Cup of Nations qualifier against Nigeria – the game that turned out to be a nightmare for the South Africans.

As we had done before, we cursed Benni for letting us down again. We hurled insults in his direction and, within soccer circles, he was labelled a traitor and someone suffering from illusions of grandeur.

But as before, we have come to the realisation that, no matter how we would love to hate the lanky former FC Porto striker, his presence in the Bafana jersey inspires confidence and even when Benni is having a day off, he ignites the dying hopes with his charismatic presence up-front.

The South African media hates him and justifiably so, because in some cases I have witnessed McCarthy trading barbs with the country’s soccer scribes at Bafana training camps. I have seen him snubbing press conferences and, at one particular moment, he told us that he would not talk to us because he didn’t think we were important to him.

But Benni is a problem child. Benni is like that member of a family that you know you should hate, but you don’t.

Should I love Benni or should I loathe this lad?

Let me take a moment to digest that thought.




Related Posts

8 Responses to “Welcome to the Benni McCarthy circus”

Why dont you ask the clown administrators at SAFA? They are the root of the troubles with Benni. After all its Benni’s boots and talent, and it belongs to him and him only.

(Report abuse)

Winnie on August 15th, 2008 at 9:08 am

From 1997 to 2008, that is 11 years later Benni is still the best striker in our country. Now can you really blame him for his swagger ?

(Report abuse)

MKT on August 15th, 2008 at 10:27 am

Ok, firstly Benni is a good striker. But that does not absolve him from his duty to his country. Imagine Wayne Rooney telling England he doesn’t feel like playing for them (not that Benni compares…) I don’t dig Benni at all!

(Report abuse)

Clyde Barrow on August 16th, 2008 at 8:50 am

Benni should have been history long time ago.Desperate coaches and writers keep resuscitating him.And by so doing they actually exagerate his aura despite the fact that his actual contribution to the Team is often less than ordinary.His excellence as a striker benefits Europe more than Bafana. Europe and not SA should be paying more attention to him or crying for him -(something that he would cherish with all his heart).

The sooner we all come to the realisation
that Benni’s irregular appearance for Bafana not only derails the team’s momentum but also delays the discovery of a potential striker, the more forwardlooking we will be. By puting faith in the available potential strikers, we would also be inspiring and imbuing them with confidence. We are achieving the opposite by kneeling down to Benni.The logic of doing this is also dangerous because Benni is not growing any younger, if anything at all, he might not be the in-thing come 2010. We might easily regret our pining for Benni and/or the chances/resources we would have denied a player whose place is taken by Benni.Forget Benni and see how he becomes another Sean Dundee!

Let’s give a player who is proudly South African a chance and full support. At heart Benni is European. Given a chance, he would switch citizenship and play for England. He only carries SA flag just so that he can draw attention on himself/to raise his profile.Why cant we see through his schemes,antics, manipulations? Forget this Drama-King!!!!

(Report abuse)

hans on August 16th, 2008 at 12:30 pm

Nice on Hans.
But as I said, we would love to loathe Benni, but the problem is, who do we have to fall back on.
I have been on the receiving end of his rants sometimes.

(Report abuse)

lux mantambo on August 16th, 2008 at 3:51 pm

You can give Benni a flash car, Spanish wife, mansion and six figure (when converted to Rands!) salary, but he will always be just an uneducated pleb from the Cape Flats. If he could articulate himself, he would tell the world that he just wants to play club football in a professional set-up with other equally talented players - as we all are aware, Bafana Bafana doesn’t offer him either.

(Report abuse)

Durban Poison on August 16th, 2008 at 11:31 pm

I’m a South African ”RUGBY SUPPORTER” but only watch english soccer. I’ve never been a SA soccer supporter because they are arrogant, over rated little spoilt brats. Now here we have Benni McCarthy who proves me right. He thinks he can choose when he wants to play for SA. He’s an over rated fat ass who should’nt ever again be chosen to represent his country. He’s lazy, he hardly ever chases a ball and relies on his team mates to get the ball to him. I hope Blackburn Rovers dumps his fat ass. Then you’ll see the prima donna run back to SA with his tail between his legs. And hopefully Santana will teach him a lesson and not pick him for SA. Hope you retire soon, Benni. Tired of your shit. Dion Mostert. (PROUDLY SOUTH AFRICAN) Ps. I hope you read this and get so pissed of that you pull a hamstring. Ps again. Appologies to everybody (accept McCarthy) reading this but I just needed to vent.

(Report abuse)

Dion on March 26th, 2009 at 5:10 pm

I found this post through a link on digg

(Report abuse)

sprint security systems on April 5th, 2011 at 2:07 am

Leave a Reply

All comments must be approved by our editors, click here to read the editorial guidelines for comments. Please allow some time for our editors to approve your comment after posting.

Send me the Thought Leader daily newsletter

profile
The award winning Luxolo “Lux” Mantambo is one of the leading sports writers in the country.

He is an avid sport fan, whose love for soccer, cricket, boxing and cricket dates back to his roots growing up in the former Transkei. He started his career with the Daily Dispatch who spotted his talent while Lux was still in College.

He has featured on various newspapers, magazines, radio and television. He is renowned for telling it as it is and admits that he is not in the business of making friends, although he realises the need to adopt a mellow attitude at times.
Technorati RSS
more posts
I’m not Luke Watson’s biggest fan, but this week, the guy has been unjustly vilified by the “conservative” media who, I suspect, have an agend...
When Mickey Arthur took over the senior national team from Ray Jennings, he bowled the media over with brave talk. Mickey spoke about brave cricket, b...
Next week, we will see the premiere of the Hansie Cronje movie and already, the nation is once again divided on the late Proteas’ skipper. Before...
This week, I got a rare opportunity to ask the country’s most paid manager Joel Natalino Santana to explain his football philosophy to me and the re...
As Bafana Bafana approach what might turn out to be the most defining game of the progress made (or lack thereof), more doubts have been cast about th...
latest activity
Blog Statistics
Total reads 7368
Total comments 90
Luxolo's tags
advertisement
All material copyright of the author, or the Mail & Guardian, unless otherwise specified
Author Login
Afrigator