« Blog Home
1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars
Loading ... Loading ...

After watching Padraig Harrington win his second consecutive Open Championship this past weekend, it prompted me to question why none of the younger golfers are coming through to step up and fight in the major championships.

At 32 years old, Tiger Woods has been holding a monopoly on the game for the past 11 years since winning his first Masters back in 1997. Now, in the past decade, why has nobody managed to take over from Tiger? If we take a cursory glance at some other major sports, we’d struggle to find an individual at the top of the world for so long.

Michael Schumacher went on to win seven Formula One world championships, but eventually a young Fernando Alonso dethroned the German. Pete Sampras ruled the grass courts of Wimbledon seven times as well, until he came up against a young Swiss named Roger Federer, who in turn went on to dominate the men’s circuit until finally this year Rafael Nadal brought an end to the Swiss supremacy. So I ask: Why are there no young golfers coming through to challenge Tiger Woods?

Quite simply, I believe it’s because golf just does not breed winners any more. Every week the PGA Tour hosts multimillion-dollar events where players are not necessarily concerned with winning. With so much money on offer, players are being given very healthy pay cheques just for appearing at events. Now let’s be honest, if most of us were paid just to appear at work and not actually strive to perform, we’d all vanish into an abyss of mediocrity. This is exactly what is happening on the Tour.

Golf fans are becoming exclusively concerned with the antics of Tiger Woods to the extent that players who are playing week in and week out are going unnoticed, yet still earning exorbitant salaries. I offer you the example of American Kenny Perry, who is the in-form player on the PGA Tour this year, having picked up three wins. In the absence of Woods, Perry would have been considered one of the favourites going into the Open. However, the American chose to skip the Major in favour of the US Bank Championship where $4-million was still on offer. I’ll suggest that Perry had the opportunity to play against lesser-known players at the US Bank Championship while all the top players were at the Open, thereby increasing his chances of pocketing a bigger prize. If there is so much money on offer for players who are not even making it to the Majors, then I can understand why players are happy to continue on the Tour.

Looking back at the Open at Royal Birkdale, one can argue it was rather nostalgic to see 53-year-old legend Greg Norman back as a contender, but why is it that a man who has not won a competitive event since 1997 is beating all the young guns currently active on the Tour? It’s time for the next generation to come through and shine.

So who are the possible heirs to Tiger’s throne?

Looking at players under 30, Sergio Garcia (28) has for years been touted as a future world number one and Major winner, but the closest the Spaniard has come to winning a Major was when he threw away the Open in a play-off defeat to Padraig Harrington at Carnoustie last year.

Australian Adam Scott (28) has 14 professional wins, but still his best finish in a Major is coming third at the 2006 PGA Championship.

South Africa’s Trevor Immelman (28) looked to be a catalyst for the young players’ emergence when he won the Masters this year, but he has since failed to replicate that form and a 19th-placed finish at the Open is not exactly going to instil fear in Tiger’s mind.

Perhaps for the next few years we will have to continue riding the Tiger success wave until the likes of Aaron Baddeley (27), JB Holmes (25) and Anthony Kim (23) can break the stranglehold.

Be that as it may, with Tiger out for the rest of year, someone else has the opportunity to make history and win the PGA Championship next month.




Related Posts
  • None

7 Responses to “Will someone finally tame the Tiger?”

Hey Justin! Great to see you online!

(Report abuse)

Cathryn R on July 21st, 2008 at 1:27 pm

Thanks Cathryn! Don’t think I don’t keep an eye on your site (don’t think I should really mention it here)

(Report abuse)

Justin Lawrence on July 21st, 2008 at 1:32 pm

Golfers typically play their best golf in their thirties and well into their forties - and to start with Tiger is just phenomenal - a once in a generation talent. I don’t think that the others aren’t trying or not interested, they just aren’t consistently as good.

(Report abuse)

Craig on July 21st, 2008 at 4:14 pm

Thanks Craig, good point. I do fully agree that Tiger is once in a generation. Yes, perhaps it is a stretch to say players aren’t trying, but would you not agree that if there was more at stake, the hunger to win would be greater on the Tour and thereby generate more competition for Tiger?

(Report abuse)

Justin Lawrence on July 21st, 2008 at 4:40 pm

Justin I think the problem is that pro golf is very rarely a game played against another golfer. You play the course on any given day.

The Ryder Cup is brilliant because the competitive instincts resurface between old rivals.

Maybe the answer is to have more teambased competitions - like club leagues?

(Report abuse)

Craig on July 23rd, 2008 at 1:00 pm

That does indeed sound like an awesome idea. That whole notion of representing your country/club does inject something extra into the competition and I think then we would see plenty of talent coming through. Imagine going around the world scouting for the next Tiger Woods to represent your team. There could really be something there…

(Report abuse)

Justin Lawrence on July 23rd, 2008 at 2:18 pm

Thought I might add that last Sunday I just happened to be seated at the 17th hole at Royal Birkdale to see Porrig slot home his eagle to secure the Open.

Apparently 200,000 people spectated over the 4 days which is huge - if tournaments became more competitive I am sure you would see similar attendance more regularly. As it is, spectating is more like a freak show - you go to see the sporty golf people up close

(Report abuse)

Craig on July 23rd, 2008 at 4:18 pm

Leave a Reply

All comments must be approved by our editors, click here to read the editorial guidelines for comments. Please allow some time for our editors to approve your comment after posting.

Send me the Thought Leader daily newsletter

profile
Justin is currently editor of the Essential Sports service at Cape Town-based agency Sunday Media. After completing his media and politics degree at UCT, this writer's work has been syndicated online to four continents, via the likes of Fox Sports, Virgin Mobile and Soccer365.

A brief sports career saw Justin become a master in the art of both putt-putt and corridor cricket before injuring himself while playing fantasy football. Nonetheless, he still holds a strong passion for all sport and is looking forward to seeing what Bafana Bafana can do in 2010.
Technorati RSS
more posts
Champions -- Chelsea The master plan of Roman Abramovich has been threatening for three seasons now and with the Blues under the management of Carl...
The British and Irish Lions got it wrong. South Africa may have played a terrible 70 minutes in the second Test on Saturday, but they proved they ...
The absence of a specialist flyhalf in the Springbok squad has left many questioning the selections of coach Peter de Villiers ahead of a gruelling se...
Pakistan fast bowler Mohammad Asif has once again found himself at the centre of controversy, having been named as the player who tested positive for ...
latest activity
Blog Statistics
Total reads 2209
Total comments 25
Justin's tags
advertisement
All material copyright of the author, or the Mail & Guardian, unless otherwise specified
Author Login
Afrigator