« Blog Home
1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars
Loading ... Loading ...

An interesting development, if you follow the touring English cricket team, has been the absence of Jacques Kallis from South Africa’s ODI squad.

I wrote a loving hymn (or chunder-worthy appraisal depending on your point of view) about JK last week, focusing on his quest for greatness, present-day anxieties have brought his importance to the forefront once more.

There is no need to repeat his importance to the Proteas’ set-up. I think as cricket fans, we all know the score.

The question that his absence does pose allows us an insight to what the future make-up of the ODI team will be come the 2011 World Cup, or after depending on when Kallis decides to give up ODIs, which I imagine he will do before he says goodbye to the Test arena.

The SA selectors have opted to bring in Ryan McLaren, and while I am a fan of this hard-working cricketer from the Free State, he is still finding his feet at international level, a totally different arena from the domestic game.

One alarming factor from Sunday’s defeat at Centurion was inability of the South African bowling attack to cut through the England batting line-up. It was South Africa’s fifth defeat in six to the Three Lions, and apart from Dale Steyn, the other bowlers didn’t look like they could dislodge their stubborn opposition.

Ten years ago it was South Africa’s batting which was their less reliable trait in pyjama cricket. Then, we had the irrepressible Shaun Pollock, Lance Klusener (before he started bowling cutters), Kallis, Ntini (though he wasn’t a mainstay yet) and one certain Allan Donald to rely on when it came to taking 10 wickets.

Often these characters were supported by “Sir” Jonty Rhodes (a knight of the oval realm and one with the air) in the field, and even Hansie with the ball. The 1999 World Cup team even had Steve Elworthy, a very under-rated bowler in his time, in the ranks to shore things up. There was also Nicky Boje, who has resurrected his local career somewhat surprisingly (never liked his bowling though).

Now the situation is a bit different. Kallis is still around, but Pollock, Donald, Klusener and Ntini (he blossomed for most of 2000s in ODI cricket) are consigned to history, though Ntini would surprise nobody if he came back [he is the leading seam bowler of this decade in Tests, with 378 wickets at 28.17. The next best is Brett Lee, with 303 wickets at 31.27].

Albie Morkel is a butcher with the bat, but is more veal then biltong when it comes to holding the ball. When he first entered the scene, his bowling was dangerous as he could swing it away at a lively pace. It could be injury or a technical deficiency, but he really needs to contribute more with the ball if he is to continue to hold down a place in the ODI team. Roelf van der Merwe doesn’t lack heart, but maybe a bit more variation wouldn’t hurt. Charl Langeveldt isn’t the worst ODI option around, but at 34 he isn’t a long-term solution. Parnell is injured, and though his potential is undoubted, his RPO is extremely high at 6.00 while in List A cricket (MTN Domestic) it isn’t that much better at 5.54. Things for Mickey to ponder indeed …

The decision to bring in Morne Morkel, who still (I say that somewhat disappointingly) has the potential to be South Africa’s next big thing after Steyn with the ball, shows the selectors cards in relation to what they believe SA is missing. For the sake of Morne, I hope he does well because if he can “click” when the Tests come around, his presence with a red cherry will add a lot of spice to what is promising to be a tough encounter.

Batting-wise, South Africa has never been better, with AB de Villiers at three and JP Duminy at four promising much, so let’s hope the boys can deliver since these two, along with Smith and Amla (with Smith the oldest at 28) promising to be the mainstay in SA’s batting order for many years to come.

So, fix the bowling and watch SA conquer? We shall see. It promises to be a cracking summer of quality cricket.




Related Posts

6 Responses to “Kallis injury puts selection posers in perspective”

i’m not convinced yet about mclaren. all-rounders are not our problem. as you and many others have said, it is our bowling. i don’t see mclaren just yet as the bowling option we need. a lot depends on morne i feel. if he can come right, we suddenly look much better on the assumption wayne is fit. three quicks offering three very different options - short, skiddy, swings it out; tall, fast, steepling bounce; left-arm, brisk, swings it both ways. and if makhaya is in the loop for the tests, then we have a seam attack that suddenly looks the part.

the problem is depth i guess. who else other than these guys can step up? abdullah? not sure about him. tsotsobe looked good the other day. a bit more pace, nice and tall. beyond these guys?

what i really crave are a handful of saffer quicks that can hurtle it down 145+ at will. like in aus - lee, johnson, bollinger, tait, even hilfenhaus, are all aorund 150. nothing can replace raw pace.

(Report abuse)

guy on November 26th, 2009 at 10:36 am

Thanks for the comment guy

Spot on about the bowling. We have Steyn, but he can’t do it alone, and being the spearhead places undue pressure on him. Morne is the guy we need to step up as such and show us what he has. We all know about his potential, and Parnell’s (who out of no-where was bowling really quickly for a period but came back slower for the ICC Champions League.

Genuine quicks are a rarity now with so much cricket going on. Lee is finished (?), Bond is playing his first Test in 2 years and SA, while having good bowlers, has no one that stands out.

Others might disagree, but McLaren is a better bowling option.

At least Harry (big fan though not everyone likes his laid back attitude) can put it on a spot with his tweakers. Can’t wait to see him bowl a classy top-spinner.

Any other bowlers we have left out apart from what guy mentioned…?

(Report abuse)

Adam Wakefield on November 26th, 2009 at 4:05 pm

love hearing you laud harry. massive fan of the guy. might not turn it square, but he’s tight and competitive. he has a definite role, and having definite roles that are executed well go a long way in balancing teams.

plaaitjies looked an interesting prospect during the champions league. he has some real gas. anyone looking after him? i guessmy point is that i’m tired and uninspired by the vasy majority of sa seamers - between 125-135kph, no real movement through the air of the deck. just dull bowlers. give me a wild paceman over dour trundlers any day of the week.

(Report abuse)

guy on November 27th, 2009 at 9:44 am

“Batting-wise, South Africa has never been better”

I think Sunday’s performance would suggest otherwise.

(Report abuse)

Chris on November 30th, 2009 at 6:02 pm

@ Chris (shot for the comment)

lol…spot on Chris. Newlands certainly deceived us. I got home from being out on Sunday keen to watch some cricket and I see the English are already batting! What a disaster. PE was GG for the Proteas from the 15th over.

It does surprise me that we were knocked over so easily. Gibbs (everyone loves a maverick…the Aussies dig Gibbs)was back and didn’t make good while Amla was dropped after a fine knock. Duminy’s form is starting to be a cause for concern. Petersen showed his colleagues how to play with a good knock under pressure.

The team has kept changing (VdM our for Botha), and while the selectors are trying to find the right combination, the sooner Kallis is back in the line-up the better.

Onto Kingsmead! If we lose to the Poms in a ODI series, I will be seriously depressed. At least Pietersen isn’t scoring (which is ominous…he usually saves his best for the Tests.)

(Report abuse)

Adam Wakefield on December 1st, 2009 at 2:47 pm

i think adam is right. batting is not an issue. yes, we played badly at pe. sports teams do that from time to time. adam’s point, as i read it, is that relatively speaking - and all things being equal - it is our bowling that will be the factor that prevents outright wins.

our batting is epic - smith, amla, kallis, de villiers, petersen, duminy. that is a power line up. yes, jp needs to get his shiz in order, and i have no doubt he will. i reckon the lad could become our best batter since readmission. compare that to our bowlers - steyn, and er, a recently in-form morkel. parnell has looked good here and there, and we need him to fire. makhaya? getting on a bit now. and mclaren is largely untested.

our bowling unit has potential, but it also has some way to go. let’s see what kingsmead delivers.

(Report abuse)

guy on December 4th, 2009 at 7:22 am

Leave a Reply

All comments must be approved by our editors, click here to read the editorial guidelines for comments. Please allow some time for our editors to approve your comment after posting.

Send me the Thought Leader daily newsletter

profile
Adam Wakefield has been a cricket enthusiast since Allan Donald attempted to kill Michael Atherton in Johannesburg in 1995/96.

After studying journalism at varsity, Adam moved to Cape Town and is currently involved with rugby journalism and assists with the National Referee Recruitment Campaign. However, he maintains his pestering love for the Lions, much to his detriment.

While Adam enjoys rugby, cricket is his first love, playing for the Fourths at varsity and currently turning out for the CBCC 2nds, with limited success. He also takes an active interest in politics and media trends.

He supports Manchester United, which he isn't too happy about...switching sides isn't kosher.

The views expressed are his own.
Technorati RSS
Adam's links
Sour Grapez
For a cynical look beyond the sports world (most of the time anyway...)
more posts
So Heinrich Brussouw is out of rugby till next year. While it is indeed bad news for Cheetahs and the Springboks, it is important to look at the facto...
I've only been involved with professional rugby journalism for just over a year, and one of the urban legends that I've picked up on my travels is tha...
I write this as South Africa do their damnedest to avoid defeat in Kolkatta, with Hashim Amla showing insane form and being backed up by Wayne Parnell...
The Super 14 began in earnest on Friday morning with the Hurricanes overcoming a deficit and defeat the highly talented (but inconsistent) Blues. S...
South African rugby enjoyed a great season in 2009, with the Springboks beating the British Lions, clean sweeping the All Blacks on the way to Vodacom...
latest activity
Blog Statistics
Total reads 12286
Total comments 150
Adam's tags
advertisement
    Mail & Guardian Online Headlines
  • National
  • Business
  • Africa
  • World
  • Sport
All material copyright of the author, or the Mail & Guardian, unless otherwise specified
Author Login
Afrigator